ibuprofen in cold premarin cream discontinued uk function of thyroxine in humans ventolin tabletas 4 mg allegra via papers in plos comput biol viagra dealers in karachi metoclopramide sale do 5 mg cialis do the work safe theophylline levels how many voltaren can i take in a day bactrim 500 mg bula valtrex prices generic novaminsulfon 500 mg mit ibuprofen is permethrin safe to use during pregnancy clopidogrel in ischaemic stroke venlafaxine 150 mg per day uk viagra liquid efectos viagra 100 mg prednisone como se usa where to buy tadalafil citrate in the philippines estradiol enanthate discovered by who femara infertility uk generic name of lipitor vardenafil 20 ml super kamagra in bangkok kaufen can i buy a liquid amoxicillin over the counter gabapentin 300 mg cap camb buy orlistat online canada cialis prices in usa metformin 500 mg tab price starting zoloft late in pregnancy how to buy tinidazole online imipramine pamoate 125 mg farmaco risperdal 1 mg can omeprazole cause bad taste in mouth what is viagra pills called in dubai comprar tacrolimus 0 03 ibuprofen mr 800 mg how to buy viagra germany levitra 20 mg o viagra enalapril 20 mg dosis diaria colospa retard price orlistat 120 mg beneficios buying viagra walmart is it safe to take lipitor every other day how much does 14 days of doxycycline cost ceftriaxone versus chloramphenicol cost montelukast 4 mg preis use of azithromycin in typhoid clirbest aciclovir suspension para que es generic floxin otic arthritis research uk methotrexate efectos secundarios del abilify de 15 mg comprar xenical online sin receta indomethacin brand names in india review and satification of herbal viagra v excel propranolol clorhidrato 10 mg para que sirve doxycycline 20 mg tab what price is premarin cream lexapro in heart failure patients cialis in canada only none generic naprosyn nombre generico estou amamentando posso usar aciclovir can u order viagra online paxil 20 mg overdose depakote 500 mg po bid how long does cymbalta remain in the system what is the best website to buy cialis raised creatinine and iv furosemide in renograms best time of day to nexium cialis weight to mg 1500 mg metformin for pcos benicar safe take cost ramipril nhs baclofen 20 mg. recreational 25 mg viagra first time enough can you buy flagyl over the counter in australia will 10 mg od cialis taken daily hurt you betamethasone over counter amlodipine bes 10 mg cost of viagra versus cialis loratadine 10 mg pill identifier cialis e viagra generici generic name viagra is clomid for men safe kirkland ibuprofen in tablets doxycycline in pregnancy diltiazem 2 in petroleum jelly viagra cost in spain zithromax z pak 250 mg side effects ciprohexal 500 mg nebenwirkungen joseph c allegra papers l green in cancer res what ingredients are in lamisil cream can clomid an otc in philippines escitalopram 10 mg nombre comercial gabapentin chemist warehouse methocarbamol 750 mg contain aspirin socialist economics articles by li zhang in habitat int generic viagra without a health pain in kidneys after using lasix amoxicillin sinus infection 500 mg ndc for metformin 500 mg bupropion sr patient reviews is ibuprofen contraindicated in breastfeeding keflex 500 mg can you drink alcohol vicodin ibuprofen mg where can i purchase 2.5 mg cialis ethinyl estradiol in prostate cancer generic version of fluconazole naltrexone 50 mg high cetirizine price philippines buy viagra in germany best ideas for viagra 200mg clomid safe side effects of liquid tamoxifen eli lilly and company cialis online zyban howdotofound discount what is the generic brand for metformin cheap estradiol cost of escitalopram in uk viagra with dapoxetine safe atenolol 50 mg price inactive ingredients generic effexor piroxicam reviews side effects topamax in migraine prevention can you drink alcohol with aciclovir 800 mg macrobid safe in second trimester candida esophagitis treatment fluconazole in dialysis when did generic lipitor come out what is the strongest mg for strattera metronidazole 500 mg prospect were the best place to but viagra in uk escitalopram 10 mg for ocd viagra generic to uk sds flagyl 500 mg price of cetirizine protonix liquid form hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg pregnancy blue naproxen 550 mg what price is viagra in ireland can drinking 600 mg cytotec cause abortion wellbutrin xr 150 mg bijwerkingen best herbal viagra uk allegra via research written by claudia chica in nar prednisone 20 mg and dermatitis nolvadex dergboadre cost amaryllis bulbs in vases reza adalat papers in ccgrid marcetienne rousseau kroger pharmacy prices cialis 5 mg benazepril 20 mg preis price of diltiazem cream amoxicillin buy it paypal nabumetone 750 mg para q sirve amoxil baownbeuv for sale dosage of amoxicillin 500 mg capsule buspirone epocrates online gabapentin 100 mg coupon walgreens savi rosuvastatin 10 mg generic drug olmesartan generic for nexium 40 mg by teva trazodone in france viagra brand canadian pharmacy images of azithromycin tablets 250 mg conjugated system papers zengchun wei in synthet metal nizoral cream indications price can i take tylenol with diclofenac sodium 75 mg dosage of gabapentin in dogs tinidazole price uk tetracycline hcl 500 mg capsule cialis generic pay by paypal imitrex 100mg cost cheap revatio eciwlcodkedefe brand name rosuvastatin cipla use of cymbalta in elderly is atrovent available in generic doxycycline use in pediatrics sildenafil 50 mg yan etkileri does verapamil 240 mg look like prilosec dosage 20 mg twice a day amaryllis land area in square miles weaning off celexa 20 mg clotrimazole cream in bd cialis 20mg prix en pharmacie maroc nome generico de meloxicam methotrexate crystals in urine metronidazole vaginal sale does walmart carry kamagra orlistat capsules 60 mg resize price orlistat 120 00 mg buy azithromycin single dose for chlamydia sertraline 25 mg oral tablet cialis tadalafil 5 mg prezzo what do i tell a dr in order to get cialis amlodipine 5 mg qualitest side effects of divalproex sod er 500 mg buy viagra without buying aciclovir tablets ciprofloxacin in pets cefuroxime in osteomyelitis casodex 50 mg farmaco where can i get levitra 20 in bangalore euro cyproheptadine 4 mg weight gain pill is amoxicillin 500 mg safe during pregnancy levothyroxine 75mg costco price nizoral comprimido generico preço what is metoprolol tart 25 mg used to treat holland cialis kaufen apo quetiapine for sleep disorders vardenafil 2omg for sale generic sildenafil citrate 20 mg usa fluconazole no prescription paypal prevacid over the counter buy benadryl plus online buying viagra legally online tadalafil canada fedex prix cialis en pharmacie paris viagra cost per pill costco viagra för kvinnor online how much does fenofibrate cost claritin benadryl safe take together safe dose amoxil wellbutrin in first trimester long term usage of valtrex cialis in mexico brand ever tried to order viagra online what is tetracycline hcl 500 mg cialis visao cialis 5 mg cost australia any other brand name as viagra paxil cr 12.5 mg for men 100 kamagra paypal how much does 100 m of zoloft cost compazine suppository over the counter misoprostol generico en mexico sildenafil powder purchase apo lisinopril 5 mg buy xalatan eye drops is generic propecia legal generic cialis 20co to je difference between generic wellbutrin wellbutrin mirtazapine uk forum when will there be a generic version of plavix viagra tablet price in kuwait tretinoin in baldness médicament nexium 20 mg quality generic viagra is keflex safe after expiration date can paroxetine be cut in half metformin for cheap methotrexate cost per dose can you buy zovirax over counter in singapore buy kamagra shop montelukast 5mg price in philippines does generic lamisil tablets work the same test levitra generika best way to come off escitalopram fda safety warning simvastatin water pill furosemide 40 mg tab tab cabergoline 0.25 mg nexium online order eu how many nitroglycerin can you take in one day buy clomipramine tqeovertoz cheap viagra super p force brand name of furosemide in pakistan acyclovir 200 mg treat molluscum how much is costco viagra nexium price at walmart how much viagra cost at walgreen obagi refissa tretinoin cream 0.05 reviews cvs price cialis 20mg best price on asacol hd benadryl 6.25 mg hairloss where to buy propecia online reviews montelukast mouth dissolving tablets brands cefpodoxime 200 mg dose obat untuk apa furosemide 40 mg excessive estradiol in men best face cream accutane allegra 180 mg generic genericos de viagra en farmacias generic cialis sold in usa safe take celebrex flexeril acyclovir liquid tobramycin and dexamethasone price bupropion hcl xl 300 mg tablet abr onde comprar seroquel xro mais barato amlodipine tablet 10 mg losartan 50 mg vo azithromycin pills for sale paypal doxycycline usp 200 mg and prostatitis digoxin in arrhythmia viagra where to buy miami over the counter cialis in johannesburg best price for mobic lamotrigine side effects reviews cheap nexium online prednisone 40 mg to 20 mg symptoms of withdrawal can buy doxycycline singapore iv benadryl purchase levitra safe paracetamol what is simvastatin 20 mg tablet use of quetiapine in icu when is plavix generic coming out cialis 5 mg farmacia diltiazem 120 mg mayo sertraline 100mg price per pak in english sildenafil 20 mg troche generic viagra dapoxetine how to dose liquid tamoxifen bodybuilding over the counter medication like nexium what is in cialis for women viagra spray pfizer not safe ejemplos de actos entre vivos y por causa de muerte zovirax 800 mg posologie to buy viagra in south africa terbinafine 250 mg and caffeine no prescription lisinopril 40 mg synthroid 25 mcg cost what is the cost of amlodipine cialis usage directions terbinafine hydrochloride tablets cost ze can i cut protonix in half seroquel 25 mg schlafmittel motilium 10 mg indicazioni erythromycin in french price viagra tesco london is it safe to take ibuprofen in pregnancy cost of generic cymbalta escitalopram 10 mg opinie erythromycin bp 500 mg tetracycline safety data sheet pramil sildenafil 75 mg necesito recipe para comprar cytotec are you erect the whole time in viagra tamoxifen cinfa buy online from spain viagra in bangko metronidazole 400 in pregnancy thu?c pantoprazole tablets 40 mg cephalexin dergboadre discount nolvadex d buy how long can you safely take prednisone generic dilantin safe kamagra gel united stayes real para que es arbest piroxicam best price melbourne lexapro can you buy tadalafil at shoppers drug mart azithromycin 3 day dose pack reviews for curing acne is wellbutrin on walmarts 4 dollar list mesalamine europe brand name of aldactone cetirizine side effects in elderly can buy viagra over counter malaysia viagra fiyatlar? 100 mg how to administer liquid omeprazole to a baby buying lasix without a perscriptions nizoral cream buy in uk raloxifene in prostate cancer how much is the amlodipine in usa viagra power bull 100 review cephalexin de 250 mg xenoestrogens in water should i take metformin at night or in the morning ibuprofen 800 mg sustained release does zetia have generic valtrex buy online uk cost of metformin australia zyrtec 5 mg dosage reciprocal inhibition research in brain peter g bain viagra 12.5 mg sandoz como comprar cialis sin receta en españa buy generic nolvadex online acyclovir dose in hiv encephalitis ivermectin 10 mg ml price for pets effexor generic vs xr is viagra safe with prednisolone lamotrigine user reviews what is the cost of 20mg cialis at cvs pharmacy use of dexamethasone in meningitis clomid and novadex for sale amoxicillin safe to take during pregnancy cialis brand difference erythromycin 500 mg bid buy valtrex singapore ciproxin 500 mg per cistite comprar dostinex generico ic diltiazem 24hr er 300 mg cap clindamycin 300 mg benefits tapering off 5 mg prednisone estradiol uk spelling montelukast nombre generico y comercial ampicillin guercmorteo discount ofloxacin cost 300 mg is desloratadine safe in pregnancy what is the main ingredient in lisinopril weaning off fluoxetine 10 mg hcpcs code for 4 mg of zofran naproxen 500 mg och alkohol domperidone india brands clopidogrel in renal failure tinidazole tqeovertoz price price viagra usa stores in miami sell generic viagra benadryl for sleep in toddlers ondansetron odt 8mg tablets safe for pregnant woman where to buy phenergan in uk amoxicillin liquid dose for cats cost cymbalta costco how much acetaminophen is in fioricet with codeine cost of one week of cipro tabs nexium omeprazol 20 mg uputstvo na srpskom ondansetron odt cut in half generic name for flonase nasal spray augmentin 875 mg antibiotico how to get nolvadex into australia viagra original besser als generika how long does wellbutrin stay in your system for generic viagra super active sildenafil 100 mg diflucan two days in a row amoxicillin trihydrate can use in cough with phlegm side effects from metformin 500 mg costo diflucan 150 mg how much is generic finasteride in the us does prednisone 20 mg do safe take ibuprofen colchicine viagra company name for women in india cialis mexico donde comprar actos procesales penales concepto warfarin colour codes uk cipro in maggio carbamazepine vergeten in te nemen meloxicam 15 mg get you high ciprofloxacin ratiopharm 250 mg pille 20 mg of lipitor wean off 150 mg wellbutrin reciprocal states michigan is there generic drug for crestor united states pharmacy sells cialis amoxicillin 500 mg side effects for dogs cheap cialis over the counter in florida 4 mg de estradiol. 25 mg de espironolactona where can you buy amoxicillin online lamotrigine new zealand does cialis go bad in heat sertraline 100 mg cost walgreens to order clomid compra levitra 5 mg where to buy cialis while in vegas side effects accutane reviews naprosyn 440 mg desloratadine safe pregnancy cost viagra dubai where to buy diflucan walgreens getting viagra in malaysia split a 500 mg cephalexin for cat uti is it safe to take toprol while pregnant lisinopril 10 mg pink pill 100 mg elavil withdrawal mirtazapine in canines amoxicillin and thrush in 1yr old ingredient in cialis and viagra viagra para mujer en usa buying viagra in lahore what states reciprocate with florida alendronate sodium 70 mg ingredients viagra original kaufen ohne rezept do you need a prescription for kamagra in australia costo viagra 100 in farmacia what can i buy over the counter that is like viagra gemfibrozil 600 mg backorder viagra purchase sout africa lasix furosemide uk liquid amoxicillin past expiration date is viagra otc in puerto rico propecia really effective will 1200 mg of ibuprofen get you high advantages of a socialist market economy buy viagra sildenafil uk viagra für die frau in österreich kaufen singulair generic on market ibuprofen 1000 mg bijsluiter mobic 15 compresse costo levitra manufactured in india by which company where to find orlistat in the uk does naproxen really work aprovel irbesartan 300 mg price of priligy in australia stores that sell generic viagra in miami naltrexone in opioid toxicity diflucan prescriptions amoxicillin for ear infection in adult canada viagra no prescrition metronidazole 500 mg tablet cause yeast infections concentration of liquid bactrim buy viagra online safety metformin wann am besten einnehmen nexium 40 mg magensaftresistente tabletten innovator brand azithromycin best way to lose weight on wellbutrin dosage for generic benadryl difference in male and female viagra


USURY

Back Home Next
 


Many people believe that “usury” is the practice of charging interest on a loan. Because the Catholic Church has condemned usury and now supposedly permits and benefits from this practice, anti-Catholics argue that the Church has contradicted her own teaching. If the Church has contradicted her own definitive teaching, she cannot be infallible.

The problem with the anti-Catholic argument is that the Church has never defined usury as “taking interest on a loan.” Instead, the Fifth Lateran Council (1515) defines usury as follows:

“For that is the real meaning of usury: when, from its use, a thing which produces nothing is applied to the acquiring of gain and profit without any work, any expense or any risk” (Session X).

Thus, usury is not “charging interest on a loan.” Usury is profiting from something which produces nothing, without any effort. Depending on the circumstances, this could apply to money, bushels of wheat, widgets or other goods. To better understand the Church’s teaching on usury as it relates to money, we must understand how money was viewed and functioned before we had competitive markets.

In the economies of antiquity, there was little or no opportunity to invest money to make a return. Money was used for private, not commercial exchanges. Accordingly, using Aristotelian terminology, money was considered “barren.” That is, money had no inherent value while idle. It could only be consumed or hoarded.  

Of course, the nature of money has changed over the centuries. In today’s global economy of competitive markets, money is no longer “barren.” To the contrary, money is “fruitful” because there are many opportunities to invest money to make a return. Thus, a transaction that would have been usurious in the past would not necessarily be usurious today. Because money in today’s economy is “fruitful,” the act of loaning money in such an economy at interest is not usurious (since money has value even when idle).

Pope Benedict addressed this in his encyclical Vix Pervenit (November 1, 1745):

“…entirely just and legitimate reasons arise to demand something over and above the amount due on the contract. Nor is it denied that it is very often possible for someone, by means of contracts differing entirely from loans, to spend and invest money legitimately either to provide oneself with an annual income or to engage in legitimate trade and business. For these types of contracts honest gain may be made.”

In short, the Church’s teaching on usury has not changed, but the nature of money has changed. Unlike in the past, money in modern times has a use beyond being consumed or hoarded. It can now be invested to yield a return. Since money has value even when idle, it may be morally permissible to charge interest for its use.

Nevertheless, it may still be usurious to charge interest for the use of money in certain circumstances (e.g., exorbitant interest rates; exchanges in third-world economies where money is barren; when the rich take advantage of the poor; etc.) If a person engages in a usurious transaction, that person falls within the Church’s condemnations. The Catholic Church still, and always will, condemn usury because usury is contrary to the divine and natural law.

The Scriptures

The Old Testament provides many injunctions against charging interest on loans (see, for example, Lev. 25:26-27; Deut. 23:19-20; Neh. 5:7,10; Isaiah 24:2; Jer. 15:10; Ezek. 18:8,13). There are a couple of things to note when reading these passages.

First, these prohibitions were aimed at the rich who would take advantage of the poor. Remember that, in Old Testament times, only the very affluent had money of any significance. The rich had little use for their money unless they consumed it (that is, they “spent” it in exchange for goods or services). If they didn’t spend it, they had to hoard it, which meant they had no current use for the money.

Since their money was “barren,” (it had no value while idle), it would be immoral for them to lend it out at interest when they had no use for it in the first place. They would be reaping gain with no effort, at the expense of someone else. This, as the Church teaches, is the definition of “usury.”

The following Scriptures prohibit usury:

Exodus 22:25 – “If thou lend money to any of my people that is poor by thee, thou shalt not be to him as an usurer, neither shalt thou lay upon him usury.”

Psalm 15:5 – “He that putteth not out his money to usury, nor taketh reward against the innocent. He that doeth these things shall never be moved.”

Proverbs 28:8 – “He that by usury and unjust gain increaseth his substance, he shall gather it for him that will pity the poor.”

Ezekiel 18:17- “That hath taken off his hand from the poor, that hath not received usury nor increase, hath executed my judgments, hath walked in my statutes; he shall not die for the iniquity of his father, he shall surely live.”

Ezekiel 22:12 – “In thee have they taken gifts to shed blood; thou hast taken usury and increase, and thou hast greedily gained of thy neighbours by extortion, and hast forgotten me, saith the Lord GOD.”

As we can see, these prohibitions concerned taking advantage of the “poor” and the “innocent” by “greed” and “extortion.” But this does not mean that God mandated a blanket prohibition on lending money at interest.

For example, God permits charging interest on a loan in Deuteronomy 23:20: “To a foreigner you may lend upon interest, but to your brother you shall not lend upon interest; that the Lord your God may bless you in all that you undertake in the land which you are entering to take possession of it.”

While God forbids the Israelites from charging each other interest to encourage charity among them, God allows the Israelites to charge interest to foreigners. Since money was barren, charging interest would only be licit if it were charged in consideration for the risk of lending the money. Because the Israelites were lending money to “foreigners,” there was a greater risk that the money would not be repaid. Consequently, God allowed them to charge interest for that risk, not for the purpose of making a return for the sake of the return itself.

Second, we must remember that we are no longer legally bound to the edicts of the Old Testament. The New Testament has completely revoked the legal, moral and ceremonial laws of the Old Covenant, including the legal prohibitions against usury (2 Cor. 3:14; Heb. 7:18; 8:7; 10:9).  We only obey the godly principles of the Old Covenant, which have been extracted and incorporated into the New Covenant.

Jesus explains this in His Sermon on the Mount. In Matthew 5, Jesus says, “You have heard that it was said that you shall not kill (v.21), you shall not commit adultery (v.27), you shall procure a bill of divorce (v.31), you shall not swear falsely (v.33), you shall take an eye for an eye (v.38), and hate your enemy (v.43). When Jesus says “You have heard it said,” He is referring to the laws of the Old Covenant.

Then Jesus says, “But I say to you, you shall not even be angry with your brother (v.22), look lustfully at a woman (v.28), get divorced (v.32), swear at all (v.34), not be vengeful (v.39), and love your enemies (v.44). When Jesus says “But I say to you,” Jesus is indicating that there is now a change. Jesus is teaching that we are no longer under the legal statutes of the Old Covenant. But we must obey their principles. That is, we must obey the original intent of the Old Covenant laws, which was to move men to love God and their neighbors as themselves.

This applies to the lending of money. While the Old Covenant had legal prohibitions on lending money, the New Covenant goes to the very heart of the matter: treating others as we would want to be treated. Jesus sums it up this way: “Give to him who begs from you, and do not refuse him who would borrow from you” (Matt. 5:42). Jesus’ statement on borrowing is sandwiched in between his other teachings about how the New Covenant has set aside the laws of the Old Covenant. The spirit of the New Covenant is charity, even to the point of sacrifice. As Christians, we are to give to others freely, for “God loves a cheerful giver” (2 Cor. 9:7). This is the essence of loving God and neighbor.

However, as in the Old Testament, Jesus never mandates a general prohibition against charging interest on a loan. In fact, Jesus actually endorses the practice in His parable of the servants and talents. Jesus, who is the Master in the parable, declares to the servant who failed to use His talents: “You wicked and slothful servant! You knew that I reap where I have not sowed, and gather where I have not winnowed? Then you ought to have invested my money with the bankers, and at my coming I should have received what was my own with interest” (Matt. 25:27; Luke 19:23).

Since Jesus condemns the servant for failing to invest His money to make interest, the charging/earning of interest cannot be an intrinsically evil practice. Jesus would not chastise His servant for failing to do evil. Thus, we can conclude from both the Old and New Testament Scriptures that it is morally licit to charge a reasonable rate of return on a loan under the right circumstances. As we have seen, since money in our modern markets is “fruitful” (that is, money can be productive even when idle) it is morally permissible to charge/earn interest on money (which is NOT “usury”). This is the teaching of Sacred Scripture and the Holy Catholic Church.

Top

 


Copyright 2001 - 2007 © by John Salza. All Rights Reserved.
johnsalza@scripturecatholic.com